(OPINION) In a stunning legal decision in Maine, a judge has ruled that a mother is forbidden from taking her daughter to church–unless it is a church approved by her ex-boyfriend.
The ruling has sparked significant controversy, as it directly challenges religious freedom and parental rights.
Liberty Counsel, a legal organization specializing in religious liberty cases, has taken immediate action to appeal the decision, arguing that it violates the U.S. Constitution and centuries of legal precedent protecting a parent’s right to raise their child in their faith.
The case stems from a dispute between the parents, who separated before their daughter was born.
For years, there was no major conflict regarding parenting decisions–until the mother and daughter began attending church together.
The father objected to his daughter wearing T-shirts with Bible verses and expressed outrage when she wanted to be baptized, calling it “indoctrination.”
A major focus of his complaint was that Calvary Chapel Bangor teaches the Bible chapter by chapter, verse by verse–an approach that is central to the Calvary Chapel movement nationwide.
To support his case, he hired a former California State University sociology professor who characterized the church as a “cult.”
The judge’s order declared that because the mother testified that her daughter’s faith in God was “more important than anything,” the court found that “Elizabeth’s beliefs about Calvary Chapel’s teachings have eclipsed her ability to make decisions that are in her daughter’s best interests.”
The judge spent nearly half of her 11-page opinion excoriating Calvary Chapel’s ministers and members for having the audacity to pray over Elizabeth and Andrea.
As a result, she is now banned from taking her daughter to Calvary Chapel or any other church the father does not approve of.
This decision has deeply alarmed Christians, as it raises concerns about how the government could interfere in religious upbringing.
If courts can dictate where a parent may or may not take their child to worship, it sets a dangerous precedent for restricting religious expression.
One of the most disturbing elements of this case is the mischaracterization of Calvary Chapel as a “cult.”
In reality, Calvary Chapel is one of the most Bible-centered Christian movements in the U.S. and beyond.
Founded by Pastor Chuck Smith in the 1960s, the Calvary Chapel movement grew out of the Jesus movement, welcoming people from all backgrounds–including many disillusioned youth from the counterculture. READ MORE
